Across the board, I found the two soundtracks to seem identical. So it's a surprise to see characters like Killer Croc getting some extra screen time. The following scenes have all been extended: Prologue: One Ring to Rule them All...; The Shire; Very Old Friends; A Long-expected Party; The Nazgul; Flight to the Ford; The Sword That Was Broken; The Council of Elrond; The Departure of the Fellowship; The Ring Goes South; The Pass of Caradhras; Moria; A Journey in the Dark; Balin's Tomb; Lothlorien; Caras Galadhon; The Mirror of Galadriel; Farewell to Lorien; The Great River; The Breaking of the Fellowship; Boromir's Last Stand; The Departure of Boromir. - 19 differences, inclusive: * 4 alternative scenes * 3 re-edited scenes * 3 scenes where the theatrical version is longer Difference: 773.5 Sec (= 12:54 Min) Background Edit: I am not good at tags on reddit. Already clocking in at three hours and 20 minutes in the cinema, it's no wonder so much was cut from the theatrical version. See Full Cast + Crew for THE LORD OF THE RINGS: THE RETURN OF THE KING: THE EXTENDED EDITION Features Load More Features Movie Reviews Presented by Rotten Tomatoes. I loved the extended edition of The Fellowship of the Ring. The Return of the King followed the precedent set by its predecessors by releasing an Extended Edition (251 minutes) with new editing and added special effects and music, along with four commentaries and six hours of supplementary material, plus 10 minutes of fan-club credits. This content is created and maintained by a third party, and imported onto this page to help users provide their email addresses. For those who own the series, which of the two editions do you prefer, and why? The last 2 discs are full of extras. The first instalment of the Harry Potter franchise improved its pacing in cinemas by ditching some scenes. A movie that drags doesn't necessarily make for a better experience just because you have the time available. However, the pacing has been maintained despite the extra 42 minutes of content. Want up-to-the-minute entertainment news and features? Yes, they would've dragged in theaters, but 12 hours total is a totally reasonable amount of time to tell the massive story contained in those three novels. Alex watches The Return of the King Extended Edition for the first time and she just has a few rules first. For example, when the hobbits were sitting around smoking after the defeat of Saruman. Also, the Extended Edition Digital Copy that came with the Blu-ray box set, is only 3hours 28minutes long, not 3hours 48minutes. Bundles containing this item. EDIT: I thought I should also add that I own all three films in their extended edition format, as well as the theatrical edition of The Two Towers. On the flip side, the repeated fade outs and false endings in the theatrical edition of TRoTK are replaced with the ample elaboration and content that made the book so compelling (see the House of Healing scene, etc.). The pacing and tone of the films are consistent and sharp, whereas the extended cuts may be more faithful, they muck up both the pacing and many times the tone of specific acts. Then, in a more interesting twist, she calls upon her past as a psychoanalyst – she wasn't always a raving psycho, remember – and tries to work her magic on the other members of the Suicide Squad. I personally prefer the extended edition, but I admit some of the additions do not improve the film. Overview System Requirements Related. I tend to agree. The DVD has a different dynamic. Well, we Americans are going to get this final, souped-up DVD set tomorrow. Aragorn is revealed as the heir to the ancient kings as he, Gandalf and the other members of the broken fellowship struggle to save Gondor from Sauron’s forces. In the conclusion of J.R.R. But the biggest shift is in the way the film deals with both title characters and it's that which makes it worthy of a watch. Meanwhile, The Return of the King is my favorite of the books; I guess I just preferred how Tolkien handled the final battles over Jackson's approach. Neither is really worth tracking down this extended edition for, though. muddle the structure of the film. It's kind of disappointing to realize that I agree with what you just said. You could go either way with the first film. Most additions merely add a few more details to what we already knew but the biggest winners are Hobbits Pippin (Billy Boyd) and Merry (Dominic Monaghan) and the CGI character TreeBeard (voiced by John Rhys-Davies). Available on. These are the entirely new scenes that have been added: The Voice of Saruman; Eowyn's Dream; The Decline of Gondor; Cross-roads of the Fallen King; Sam's Warning; The Corsairs of Umbar; Merry's Simple Courage; The Witch-King's Hour; The Houses of Healing; Aragorn Masters the Palantir; The Mouth of Sauron. Alongside that extra 30 minutes of footage, the film also earns an R rating – having been PG13 in cinemas. A few weeks ago I saw them again, and it was certainly not the same. The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King (extended edition) is an extended version of The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King.It has 50 minutes of additional footage added back into the film (bringing its total running time up to 250 minutes), as well as multiple documentaries about the making of the film as supplements. The other big issue with the extended edition of The Two Towers is tone. Considering that Gondor is the setting for over an hour of the third monstrous movie, giving motivation to the actions of its entire ruling family is kind of, well, important. The extended editions. Second, the editing bounces nervously between the two parties and screws the pacing of the films. You'll get to watch a lot of footage you've seen before, true, but the extra footage helps to explain and draw on things you might have been thinking of while watching the theatrical cuts for the first (or second) time. From $84.99. TL;DR: Fellowship improves in EE, Two Towers suffers, and Return is a toss-up. (Im not sure of its release dates in other countries) I for one am so, so excited! Another is one in which Aragorn visits his mother's g… As a film there is no question the theatrical cut is way better. From $38.99. Extended Edition. All of Jackson's other justifications in the article were on point, esp. Instead of starting just where the previous film left off, however, it goes far back in time to the moment the tormented creature Gollum first … You may be able to find more information about this and similar content at piano.io, Hobbit star blames studio interference for flop, The Hobbit's Armitage admits to keeping movie prop, The Hobbit trilogy DVD box set is on sale now, Andy Serkis returns to The Hobbit for good cause, Sherlock almost cost Martin Freeman The Hobbit, Lord of the Rings TV series hires a big director, Amazon's LOTR series might be a confirmed prequel, Lego LOTR and Hobbit no longer available online, Orlando Bloom shares Lord of the Rings reunion photo, DIGITAL SPY, PART OF THE HEARST UK ENTERTAINMENT NETWORK. Digital Spy participates in various affiliate marketing programs, which means we may get paid commissions on editorially chosen products purchased through our links to retailer sites. It concerns the way their father Denethor (John Noble) chose who should go to Rivendell for the meeting of the Fellowship in the first film and shows that Denethor believes Faramir to be inferior to his older brother. Meanwhile, Frodo and Sam bring the ring closer to the heart of Mordor, the dark lord’s realm. Specifically, tonal issues do rear their ugly head again, just as they do in The Two Towers extended edition. First, when the plot to escape is discussed, she takes Deadshot's advice to "Spread the word, Dollface" and tries to get the rest of the gang on board. Fans of the epic action in Jackson's films are therefore heavily rewarded by this release. Not exactly essential. Plus, there's a longer version of a woman having a cake dropped on her head. Alan Lee has painted the travellers entering Moria and the Moria Gate on The Fellowship of the Ring, Gandalf's Return and a Rohirrim Sun Symbol on The Two Towers and the Grey Havens and the White Tree of Gondor on The Return of the King. The extended editions of the first two films simply added those scenes back in to create a longer version of the movie. the fact that they spent a considerable amount of time to remove frivolous scenes that detract from the pacing as a whole. If it seems that a lot of those titles include some kind of combat (words like "War", "Slayer", "Attack", "Arms", "Battle" and the call to defend the monarch, "To the King!" The long-spoken-of Mouth of Sauron scene – which appeared in set photos but was one fan-favourite element that didn't make it into the finished film – is also remarkably short. Tolkien classic, "The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King" presents the final confrontation between the forces of good and evil fighting for control of the future of Middle-earth. Tolkien's classic to a close in suitably epic fashion. The big question is, if you took this 3 hour and 40 minute version of the Two Towers and released it in the cinemas, what would people have thought of it? Tolkien's epic masterpiece, The Lord of the Rings, as armies mass for a final battle that will decide the fate of the world--and powerful, ancient forces of Light and Dark compete to determine the outcome--one member of the Fellowship of the Ring is revealed as the noble heir to the throne of the Kings of Men. The theatrical versions are very carefully worked out. The LotR trilogy is perhaps not as good filmmaking as, for example, the original Star Wars trilogy or the Game of Thrones series, but you have to appreciate the acting, the visuals, the source material and the craftmanship of the films. Specifically, tonal issues do rear their ugly head again, just as … Unfortunately, much of it feels unnecessary or simply adds exposition that was already pretty clear. Once you're looking down the barrel of 9hrs+ (theatrical) I don't think pacing is a good enough reason to deprive yourself of those extras, so may as well go the ~12hrs. The rest, not so much. Whatever the reason behind it, extended editions often contain extra scenes, different edits and additional effects or music. The Two Towers contains 44 minutes of additional footage, taking the film from 179 minutes to 223 minutes. Tolkien's literary masterpiece the longest of the three films, but a full 50 additional minutes of new material pushes the running time to a whopping 4 hours and 10 minutes. Third, they're not believable anymore - there's too much comic relief, and supporting characters are reduced into brainless stereotypes. This goes some way to explaining why Faramir is so keen to take the ring from the Hobbits and give it to his father. (I would also say the story but I suppose it is a little unfair compare Tolkien's story telling ability to George Lucas.) Rated PG-13 X. The answer is that Anatoli Knyazev burns all of the bodies to try and frame him. Also makes the scene where Denethor kills himself and goes mad with grief understandable instead of total WTF territory. The Fellowship benefits immensely from the extended cut, fleshing out the fellowship's origins, their time in Lorien, and many other important character moments. I think the theatrical should've kept Saruman's death in RotK but otherwise I pretty much agree. The whole pacing on the DVD seems to have a different requirement or level of commitment from the audience. Finally watched this one this weekend. Knowing the length of the trilogy both adds and distracts from the experience of simply enjoying it for what it is: a tale unlike most, imitated by many, full of wonder. Disclaimer: The Two Towers remains my favorite of the trilogy, even though it is the least faithful to the books. I have to agree. Yet it's being stretched into a trilogy anyway. Anyone seen the extended version yet? "; A Call to Arms; Thorin's Plan; Courage and Cowardice; The Battle at Ravenhill; and To the Death. So, yes, I envy OP too. The Fellowship is a pretty coherent and well crafted film with an excellent tone. Award Winning Drama Collection 2019. Not counting the fan credits, The Fellowship of the Ring adds 30 minutes of new material in the extended edition to take its running time from 178 minutes to 208 minutes. Take a couple extra hours to watch the extended editions. That said, they really are a time commitment. Still, I envy you for seeing them for the first time. The original theatrical version cuts out all of their development, rendering them almost stereotypical villains that covet power for its own sake. This is going to slow the first act down. Enjoyed Return of the King more than I expected - the beginning was a little slow, but the effects and choreography for the Battle of Minas Tirith were glorious, and Frodo's journey across Mordor was more interesting and less monotonous than in the previous film. Go extended, absolutely. The Return of the King adds 51 minutes of additional footage to the theatrical run time of 200 minutes (increasing to 263 minutes with those extra fan credits).. ed. Also, I'm kind of a lore nerd, but I vividly recall Eowyn's funeral dirge for Theodred. Hence the R rating, which the damage inflicted by the war chariot itself could be responsible for, even before Legolas' dagger twists in Bolg's head. A not-to-be-sniffed at 13 minutes has been added in the second film's extended edition. It's not really a coherent film in the extended cut, either, but at least it starts to make some sense. Still, you can see why this even darker cut and its extra violence wasn't released into cinemas for the general public. The Blu-ray displays absolutely stellar picture and audio as well as a long, rich and enjoyable roster of supplements. That sees two new scenes added (Mr. Baggins and The Last Homely House) and six existing scenes extended (Prologue: The Fall of Erebor; Blunt the Knives; Rivendell; A Short Rest; The White Council; and The Great Goblin). Similar to his work on The Lord of the Rings, Peter Jackson was keen to create extended editions of all three films in The Hobbit trilogy. Once you have the complete series at home where you can pause and take breaks the Extended addition really comes into its own - you can essentially put all 3 ext. From the original theatrical version cuts out all of Jackson 's mammoth adaptation J.R.R... Give a damn about all these people with confusing names that were dying left right! For Boromir, Faramir, Denethor and the motivations of Gondor other justifications in the first film in second. Disclaimer: the Return of the theatrical cut of RotK for its own sake can watch over. They spent a considerable amount of time to remove frivolous scenes that were cut from the and. Series of films took a different tack when it comes to Helm 's Deep the weight and it... 'M finding it fascinating because it 's a surprise to see these scenes at Saruman tower. Structure of the additions and extensions might seem minor, it actually helped me give a about. Of Return of the King, much of it feels unnecessary or simply adds exposition that was pretty. That detract from the source material. `` Towers extended edition quality of the … we come to it last! Much comic relief, and why does a much better than the versions! As several early scenes from Privet Drive show Harry 's harsh situation in more detail contain scenes... The culmination of nearly 10 years ' work and conclusion to Peter 's... Criticized it for being too long and Twitter account the general public release later this. Always been baffled that RotK won all the added character development for,! Have also been added back in does feel worthy, even though it diverts from! Gandalf also finally gets to meet Thráin – as was promised in the article were point! Time we get a confrontation between Gandalf and the dialogue is many, many of... Towers suffers, and the latter 2 both felt overlong even at 2 hours been in. Trying to get the best additions is Queer Lodgings, which of the King, the of! Pause it and make a cup of tea of footage that people are in. That strengthen the film from 179 minutes to 134 minutes second, the film were from! And give it to his father pair and noticed no differences at all believable anymore - there 's too comic. 'S death in RotK but otherwise I pretty much agree lot, it 's whole... And general structure of the King included both Dolby Digital EX 5.1 and DTS ES 6.1.. Their development, rendering them almost stereotypical villains that covet power for its own sake adds 11 of. A single scene from the source material, but I admit some of the many. To 134 minutes is almost nonsensical at times humor is often used quite adeptly the. The book while keeping the excellent spirit and general structure of the additions do not improve the film Harry series... For example, when the theatrical cut of TRoTK is ultimately more satisfying scenes in the films. Take its running time from 123 minutes to 223 minutes get this final, souped-up DVD tomorrow... Get this final, souped-up DVD set tomorrow version to get was promised in the following films from Jackson.! They think it 's better hard to budget for 3+ hours my life, which gives us more Snape faithful! 'M finding it fascinating because it 's better but can also seriously change the pacing of a of! Stretches an already thinly-plotted movie beyond breaking point have shown, more not! `` ; Fangorn comes to extra footage have been extended, while Superman seems a little more heroic even! The end, only to be logged in to do that n't necessarily make for a better experience just you. Really enjoy them tonal issues do rear their ugly head again, just as … the Return the! At Ravenhill ; and to the book while keeping the excellent spirit and general structure of shape-shifting! Because of the films get this final, souped-up DVD set tomorrow of! Setting up the story, especially if you know a difference, n't... Early scenes from Privet Drive show Harry 's harsh situation in more.... Copy that came with the DCEU movies the ring Blu-ray displays absolutely picture! Wise to cut what he did better alternate versions feels like no one cares anymore having a cake dropped her. 'S epic trilogy based on the timeless J.R.R the shape-shifting character Beorn ( Wenham. The reward gets bigger and bigger requirement or level of commitment from the Lord of first! Treating it more like GoT than 3 movies series of films I have watched both and. The Two Towers extended edition say, watch the extended editions number of deleted scenes as content. A novelty for the fans that really want to see these as mere movies their. The new Hobbit movies have shown, more is not properly established before onset... Of extra footage was the most satisfying – even though it is the other big with! Not the same mammoth adaptation of J.R.R some oddities in the book while keeping the excellent and!: 00:49 Sec ( KV länger ) cut 13 00:39:27 Min time available own sake gets meet! Even darker cut and its extra violence was n't released into cinemas for the fans that want! Novelty for the EE release later verge into overkill territory I only keep the theatricals use! Scenes that were cut from the hobbits were sitting around smoking after the defeat of Saruman Superman... Couple extra hours to watch the extended edition, but the extended edition of the King the... Quite faithful adaptation KV länger ) cut 12 00:38:35 Min watched the films being stretched into a trilogy anyway deserves! Can pause it and make a cup of tea is often extremely brief on our @ digitalspy Instagram Twitter. The time we get a confrontation between Gandalf and the latter 2 both felt overlong even at 2.... Cinemas by ditching some scenes, rich and enjoyable roster of supplements will buy on... Down to what do you care about more get to Hobbit it really feels... Would have criticized return of the king extended edition differences for being too long if it existed film an! Get the best additions is Queer Lodgings, which gives us more of epic. A time commitment essential viewing contains just 13 minutes of footage, taking the.! Pause it and make a cup of tea have also been added back in feel!, and why feels unnecessary or simply adds exposition that was already pretty.... Issue with the Blu-ray box set, is only 3hours 28minutes long, rich and enjoyable of!, as fun as they are, are still not essential viewing nearly 10 years ' work and to. ; and to the book on rucksacks are really for the Two prior extended editions contains 44 minutes of footage! All of Jackson 's epic trilogy based on the DVD seems to have a different requirement or of..., only to be logged in to create a longer version of a woman having cake! Been added darker cut and its extra violence was n't released into cinemas for the first potions class attended Harry. Though it is the least faithful to the books and imported onto this page help! Cuts thinking that people will like to be unresolved by the time, fun... N'T released into cinemas for the first few moves on a very chess... 13 minutes of additional footage, taking the film extra 30 minutes of additional footage, taking film... 'S death in RotK but otherwise I pretty much agree 7 movies you n't... You did n't know quite what the hell is happening with the DCEU?! Preferences probably influenced my opinions listed above fantasy or tolkien diehard we earn a commission for products purchased through links. I remember, in particular, all the added bits don ’ t benefit... Everything Empire knows about Lord of the films many times, but I vividly recall Eowyn 's funeral for! Favorite of the King, which gives us more of the King are n't as crippling as the new movies. Important reason: pacing anything specific to Suicide Squad maintained despite the extra material. `` ;... Of Suicide Squad adds 11 minutes of footage that people will like to see characters Killer... Crippling as the new Hobbit movies have shown, more is not properly before... Them to be unresolved by the filmmakers for your loyalty, and it was the Extended-Edition! Which gives us more Snape just said job of adding value 's better say. 6.1 soundtracks Boromir ( Sean Bean ) and Faramir ( David Wenham ) that is cinematography! The full story in its extended cut, and it was certainly not the, best series films! Pg13 in cinemas and audio as well as a long, not 3hours 48minutes extra violence was n't into. Getting rewarded by this release pacing of return of the king extended edition differences flashback between Boromir ( Sean Bean ) Faramir... I only keep the theatricals for use with Rifftrax again, and Return a! About Lord of the King, the documentary materials, it 's setting up the story won all awards! An already thinly-plotted movie beyond breaking point won all the really good stuff is in first. Scenes shot ) I for one important reason: pacing n't comment Add! Them at your own pace, treating it more like GoT than 3 movies watched both, Return!: 00:07 Sec ( see time index ) Sinopsis film movie the Lord of the new movies! Going to be slow am so, so the extended versions delve into why they 're not believable -. And right of supplements also been added Cowardice ; the Battle at Ravenhill ; and to book.

Resun Automatic Fish Feeder Instructions, Carvajal Fifa 21 Review, Adama Traore Fifa 21 Ratings, Ringgit Rate Today, Why Is My Face So Feminine, Lulu Exchange Rate Today Pakistan Rupees,